Top PayScale Alternatives: Competitors and Solutions

by | Published on Nov 11, 2023 | Last Updated on Apr 3, 2024 | Compensation

Top Compensation Providers

The freshest salary benchmarking data by industry, location, and revenue size.

PayScale Alternatives - Main Image

Selecting the right compensation management software is essential for businesses to attract, retain, and motivate top talent. With the ever-changing landscape of compensation planning and talent management, choosing a software solution that meets the unique needs of your organization is vital. This article will guide you through the top PayScale competitors, exploring features, benefits, and the advantages they bring to your organization.

From SalaryCube’s up-to-date salary benchmarking data to SimplyMerit’s user-friendly dashboard interface, let’s dive into these top compensation management software alternatives and discover how they can enhance your organization’s talent management strategy.

Key Takeaways

  • Discover the top PayScale alternatives and competitors providing streamlined HR services, data-driven pay decisions and company culture support.

  • Compare features and benefits including user experience, integration capabilities, customer support options.

  • Assess organization needs to select best compensation management solution for pricing, scalability & flexibility.

Top Compensation Management Software Alternatives to PayScale MarketPay

The market offers a variety of PayScale MarketPay alternatives, each with unique features and benefits designed to improve compensation management. Five leading competitors include:

  • SalaryCube

  • Pave

  • CompXL

  • SimplyMerit

  • CompTrak

We will now examine each of these best alternatives and their offerings in detail, with details provided by various vendors.


SalaryCube stands out as a top PayScale alternative with robust features, providing the most up-to-date salary benchmarking data across industries, locations, and revenue sizes. SalaryCube ensures the accuracy and relevance of their salary data by continuously collecting and analyzing compensation data from various sources, including survey data, the transparent career community, and market research. This provides organizations with the necessary data to make compensation decisions that maintain their competitiveness in the market.

Covering all industry sectors within the US, SalaryCube offers segmented salary benchmarking data based on industry, location, and revenue size. This provides users with relevant data based on their specific region and company size, guaranteeing precise and comprehensive information. Take advantage of their free demo to see how SalaryCube can benefit your organization.

Pave Compensation Data

Pave is a comprehensive software solution with the following features:

  • User-friendly interface

  • Customizable features

  • Consolidates data to a uniform reference framework, ensuring benchmarking is not traceable to a specific individual

  • Free demo

  • Prioritizes data security, employing physical, technical, and organizational safeguards

  • Has received SOC 2 Type II certification

Users favor Pave’s user-friendly interface and simple navigation. With its toolset, companies can manage and communicate compensation in real-time, improving HR services and enabling managers to make decisions about salaries based on data.


CompXL is another one of the PayScale alternatives that offers a flexible and cost-effective automated compensation solution for businesses of all sizes. It provides a range of features like branded salary adjustment letters, budgeting capabilities, multi-currency deployment, and integration with ADP Workforce Now. CompXL is suitable for small companies with fewer than 250 employees, as well as large companies with over 25,000 employees.

Pricing for CompXL starts at $9,999 per year and increases based on the number of employees and distinct cycles per year. Combining the flexibility of Excel with the power of the cloud, CompXL enables simple customization and scalability, accommodating intricate pay-for-performance strategies.


SimplyMerit is a cloud-based vendor that offers the following features:

  • Simplifies management with real-time updates

  • Provides currency conversion capabilities

  • Streamlines the management of compensation and merit increases

  • Enables adjustments that would typically take weeks to complete manually to be resolved in a matter of minutes.

SimplyMerit presents a set of features that differentiate it from other compensation management solutions. These features include:

  • Real-time reporting

  • Approval process control

  • Customization options

  • Bonus management

  • Performance management

  • Interview scheduling

  • Email management

  • Free demo

It provides an efficient approach to managing salaries, removing the need for managing several spreadsheets by consolidating all compensation-related data and bonus management into a single system.


CompTrak is another one of the PayScale alternatives that offers a robust compensation management platform that offers the following features:

  • Seamless integration with other HR systems

  • User and access management

  • Audit and compliance management

  • Activity tracking

  • Contract automation

  • Compensation planning

  • Total rewards statements

CompTrak offers the following other aspects:

  • Capability to manage different types of payrolls and pay cycles

  • Customization options to suit the growth and evolving compensation plans of different businesses

  • Integration with Workday, SAP SuccessFactors, Oracle HCM, and UKG, ensuring smooth connections with existing HR systems.

Enhancing Talent Management with PayScale Competitors

PayScale competitors enhance talent management by offering the following features:

  • Streamlined HR services

  • Data-driven pay decisions

  • Support for company culture

  • Automated payroll processing

  • Employee self-service

  • Compliance management

  • Customizable modules for HR services

  • Ability to connect with other HR systems

These features create a supportive and engaging work environment for employees.

Streamlined HR Services

Streamlined HR services incorporate easy-to-use interfaces, customizable features, and seamless integration with existing HR systems. SalaryCube, for example, offers automation and simplification of compensation design processes and unique features that optimize employee operations and workforce management.

Pave, on the other hand, streamlines HR services through customization, providing teams with:

  • Customizable workflows

  • Approval processes

  • Budgeting tools

  • Self-service portals

These features foster a culture of self-sufficiency and simplify HR processes.

Data-driven Pay Decisions

Data-driven pay decisions are supported by up-to-date salary benchmarking data and advanced analytics tools. SalaryCube, for instance, offers the freshest salary benchmarking data by industry, location, and revenue size. This allows organizations to make informed compensation decisions and remain competitive in the labor market.

Pave competitors, such as Spiff, facilitate data-driven pay decisions by providing advanced analytics and reporting capabilities. These tools allow finance and sales teams to analyze compensation data, visualize compensation plans, and make informed decisions based on the insights gained.

Supporting Company Culture

Supporting company culture involves offering transparency, fairness, and flexibility in compensation management. SalaryCube promotes pay transparency, which helps mitigate pay gaps and decreases employee turnover. By openly disclosing compensation information, SalaryCube holds companies accountable for pay fairness and equity, helps close gender and racial inequities, and supports the transparent career community.

Other PayScale alternatives and competitors that prioritize company culture include:

  • Aeqium

  • Comprehensive


  • Comparably

  • Equilar

  • Glassdoor

  • Hay Group

These competitors provide various solutions and tools such as employee feedback and engagement platforms, transparent salary information, diversity and inclusion initiatives, and resources for talent management, hiring and development. These offerings help organizations create a supportive and engaging work environment for their employees.

Comparing Features and Benefits of PayScale Competitors

PayScale competitors offer a variety of features and benefits, including user experience, integration capabilities, and customer support options.

Next, we will examine these aspects in more depth and contrast the offerings of each leading alternative as PayScale compares them to MarketPay.

User Experience

User experience encompasses intuitive interfaces, customizable features, and a user-friendly experience for both HR professionals and employees. For example, SalaryCube provides an easy-to-use interface, comprehensive salary data, customizable reports, and benchmarking tools.

Pave offers a user-friendly app, intuitive analytics tools, and real-time market data, ensuring an intuitive user experience. Its collection of tools aids companies in handling and communicating compensation in real-time, enhancing HR services, and productivity and enabling managers to make data-driven decisions.

Integration Capabilities

Integration capabilities involve seamless connections with existing HR systems, CRMs, and ERPs. For instance, SalaryCube integrates with HR systems such as HRSoft, Paycom, and CompAnalyst, ensuring a smooth experience for users.

CompXL offers integration with various HR systems, including:

  • ADP Workforce NOW

  • UKG Pro

  • BambooHR

  • Ceridian

  • Workday

This enables enhanced collaboration and eliminates data silos, providing enterprises with a connected and efficient compensation management process.

Customer Support

Customer support includes responsive and knowledgeable assistance, as well as ongoing updates and improvements to the software. SalaryCube, for example, offers support from a knowledgeable team of compensation specialists.

CompTrak, on the other hand, provides 24/7 customer support service, with support available in multiple languages and time zones, ensuring that clients receive assistance whenever they need it. This degree of customer support is necessary to help organizations fully utilize their chosen compensation management software.

Choosing the Right Compensation Management Solution for Your Organization

Finding the right compensation management solution for your organization involves assessing your needs, evaluating pricing and deployment options, and considering scalability and flexibility in compensation planning.

Next, we will delve into these factors more deeply, assisting you in choosing the most suitable compensation management software for your organization.

Assessing Your Organization’s Needs

Assessing your organization’s needs requires identification and review of your compensation structure, company size, and industry-specific requirements. Key considerations when determining your compensation structure include internal equity, transparency, job analysis and evaluation, compensation philosophy, market competitiveness, ease of management, and growth and development.

Moreover, company size can influence the choice of compensation management software, as larger organizations may require more comprehensive and scalable solutions, while smaller companies and startups may prioritize cost-effectiveness and simplicity.

Evaluating Pricing and Deployment Options

Evaluating pricing and deployment options involves comparing subscription fees, implementation costs, and cloud-based or on-premise solutions. For instance, Pave and SalaryCube’s subscription fee is not publicly disclosed.

Implementation costs can also vary, with SalaryCube’s costs ranging from $50,000 to $250,000, depending on the budget and the complexity of the desired implementation. When it comes to deployment, some solutions may offer cloud-based or on-premise options, each with its own advantages and disadvantages.

Considering Scalability and Flexibility

Choosing a solution that can evolve with your organization and adapt to shifting compensation strategies is vital for sustained success. For instance, Pave is highly adaptable tool when it comes to changing compensation strategies, providing resources and guides to aid organizations in revising their compensation philosophies and processes to reflect current trends.

Similarly, CompXL offers the flexibility of an Excel formula engine and the scalability and efficiency of cloud software to ensure scalability and flexibility in its compensation management system. By taking into account these factors, you can opt for a compensation management solution that will continue to serve your organization in the long run.


In conclusion, finding the right compensation management software is crucial for organizations seeking to attract, retain, and motivate top talent. This article has explored the top alternatives to PayScale MarketPay, including SalaryCube, Pave, CompXL, SimplyMerit, and CompTrak. Each of these competitors offers unique features and benefits, such as user experience, integration capabilities, and customer support.

By assessing your organization’s needs, evaluating pricing and deployment options, and considering scalability and flexibility, you can find the perfect compensation management solution to enhance your talent management strategy and ensure the continued success of your organization.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is PayScale or glassdoor better?

Payscale is likely the better source for accurate salary data due to the verified salaries and larger selection of companies, so it is the recommended source.

What type of business is PayScale?

Payscale is an American compensation software and data company which provides organizations with a modern and scalable technology platform to help manage employee compensation, while offering employees insight into their worth in the job market. As the industry leader in compensation data and technology, Payscale helps organizations #getpayright and is the only technology solution for managing compensation that provides employers with multiple streams of fresh, transparently curated, and validated salary data.

Who are salary com competitors?’s competitors include Comprehensive, Pave, and Comparably, all of which offer employee compensation platforms to help companies make pay decisions without requiring spreadsheets.

What are the top alternatives to PayScale MarketPay?

The top PayScale alternatives include SalaryCube, Pave, CompXL, SimplyMerit, and CompTrak.

Which HR systems can CompXL integrate with?

CompXL can integrate with ADP Workforce NOW, UKG Pro, BambooHR, Ceridian, and Workday HR systems.